PDA

View Full Version : JL 12W3's or W6's



Firewater
03-29-2005, 03:20 PM
I'm looking to get two 12's to finish off my system powered by two 500/1's.
Will I expect a huge difference between the two? There is the money issue, but I want it to sound good. Al & Eds in Thousand Oaks seem to be giving me a good deal either way

SoundsGood
03-29-2005, 06:56 PM
I have two 12w3's. JL recommends 300Watts RMS and 500 max. With two JL 500/1's I would definitely go with the 12w6's. All your cash is already in the amps! Go with subs that can handle it IMO.

Scarlett Fever
03-29-2005, 07:07 PM
If you are planning on running one 500/1 to each sub I would definitely go with the W6s. Their optimal RMS Wattage is around 400 watts. Thats a little too much power for the W3's because their optimal is about 300 watts. The cost is a factor but they do use the same size sealed box (1.25cu ft per woofer).
Just a thought if you haven't bought the amps yet...I would go with one 1000/1. The reason is that the amps are rated down to 1.5 Ohm. The lowest you could get wiring one sub to one amp would 1 ohm if you wired a dual voice coil 2 ohm sub in parallel which is too low for the amp, you would be forced to wire a 4 ohm dual voice coil down to 2 ohms. However if you had both subs run off of one amp you could use one 4 ohm sub wired in parallel to get a 2 ohm load and one 2 ohm sub wired in parallel to get a 1 ohm load and then wire them in parallel together to get an overall 1.5 ohm load to the amp.
A 1.5 ohm load to the 1000/1 will pull more power then a 2 ohm load to each 500/1 separately.

Phat Matt
03-29-2005, 09:56 PM
If you are planning on running one 500/1 to each sub I would definitely go with the W6s. Their optimal RMS Wattage is around 400 watts. Thats a little too much power for the W3's because their optimal is about 300 watts. The cost is a factor but they do use the same size sealed box (1.25cu ft per woofer).
Just a thought if you haven't bought the amps yet...I would go with one 1000/1. The reason is that the amps are rated down to 1.5 Ohm. The lowest you could get wiring one sub to one amp would 1 ohm if you wired a dual voice coil 2 ohm sub in parallel which is too low for the amp, you would be forced to wire a 4 ohm dual voice coil down to 2 ohms. However if you had both subs run off of one amp you could use one 4 ohm sub wired in parallel to get a 2 ohm load and one 2 ohm sub wired in parallel to get a 1 ohm load and then wire them in parallel together to get an overall 1.5 ohm load to the amp.
A 1.5 ohm load to the 1000/1 will pull more power then a 2 ohm load to each 500/1 separately.
Those amps put out the same power wired at 1.5 or 4 ohms.

ROZ
03-29-2005, 10:27 PM
If you are planning on running one 500/1 to each sub I would definitely go with the W6s. Their optimal RMS Wattage is around 400 watts. Thats a little too much power for the W3's because their optimal is about 300 watts. The cost is a factor but they do use the same size sealed box (1.25cu ft per woofer).
Just a thought if you haven't bought the amps yet...I would go with one 1000/1. The reason is that the amps are rated down to 1.5 Ohm. The lowest you could get wiring one sub to one amp would 1 ohm if you wired a dual voice coil 2 ohm sub in parallel which is too low for the amp, you would be forced to wire a 4 ohm dual voice coil down to 2 ohms. However if you had both subs run off of one amp you could use one 4 ohm sub wired in parallel to get a 2 ohm load and one 2 ohm sub wired in parallel to get a 1 ohm load and then wire them in parallel together to get an overall 1.5 ohm load to the amp.
Moving air AND current are a goal... 2 power supplies will definitely move current...
As Matt stated, the slash line amps output is the same 1.5-4ohms... The amp puts out over 500watts anyways(remember that impedance changes durning music play)....500 is the minimum you get.
w6 will not only handle more power reliably, but it's a better sounding speaker. Also the amp running at 4ohms has less distortion.
Can a w3v2 handle a 500/1? Yes, but for how long......
A 1.5 ohm load to the 1000/1 will pull more power then a 2 ohm load to each 500/1 separately. They pull current and produce power ;) :D

Scarlett Fever
03-30-2005, 11:47 AM
Those amps put out the same power wired at 1.5 or 4 ohms.
That doesnt make sense since ohms are a measurement of resistance. Less resistence means more current flowing. It might say that in the manual but then if we believed everything that said where would we be?

ROZ
03-30-2005, 12:06 PM
That doesnt make sense since ohms are a measurement of resistance. Less resistence means more current flowing. It might say that in the manual but then if we believed everything that said where would we be?
Under normal circunstances, yes... JL amps are designed differently...
Yes, resistance between 1.5ohms and 4 ohms the output is the same... Loads less than the 1.5 it makes more power because frequencies when playing music fluctuate impedance on the driver....
As a result, a retailer doesn't have to have both 2 and 4ohm drivers instock at all times to get the most out of the JL slash line amp.

Phat Matt
03-30-2005, 01:02 PM
Under normal circunstances, yes... JL amps are designed differently...
Yes, resistance between 1.5ohms and 4 ohms the output is the same... Loads less than the 1.5 it makes more power because frequencies when playing music fluctuate impedance on the driver....
As a result, a retailer doesn't have to have both 2 and 4ohm drivers instock at all times to get the most out of the JL slash line amp.
Thanks Roz. ;)

STV_Keith
03-30-2005, 03:52 PM
Might you consider any other speakers? Take a look at the Resonant Engineering (http://www.reaudio.com/) subs. I have a pair of their SX series 10's that kick serious butt. They are rated for 1000w RMS, 2000w peak. They offer 12's (and other sizes) as well.
I paid about $100 per sub less for my 10's than JL 10w6's as well.

NOTALENT
03-31-2005, 07:16 AM
Might you consider any other speakers? Take a look at the Resonant Engineering (http://www.reaudio.com/) subs. I have a pair of their SX series 10's that kick serious butt. They are rated for 1000w RMS, 2000w peak. They offer 12's (and other sizes) as well.
I paid about $100 per sub less for my 10's than JL 10w6's as well.
Hey keith where did u pick the subs up at??

STV_Keith
03-31-2005, 09:26 AM
A friend of mine runs the place. If you're going to the RWYB this weekend, look me up and I'll demo them for ya. :)

NOTALENT
03-31-2005, 09:45 AM
A friend of mine runs the place. If you're going to the RWYB this weekend, look me up and I'll demo them for ya. :)
I wish..but I dont think I have enough man power to put those oars to row!! :D I should be up and running this week or next..just in time for summer!!

CornWater
03-31-2005, 10:27 AM
I run three 12W6's in the boat and love them... I have had these speakers for about 4 years, and they still sound great.. I have 12W3's in my Excursion, and they sound great also... but the 12W6's just love power, the more the better..

Firewater
03-31-2005, 05:40 PM
Is there a power difference and heat issue with either running 2 500/1 or a 1000/1?
If I'm running one of those choices, plus a 300/4 which I already have installed, what do you guys think I should run battery wise? Thanks in advance

Phat Matt
03-31-2005, 07:22 PM
Is there a power difference and heat issue with either running 2 500/1 or a 1000/1?
If I'm running one of those choices, plus a 300/4 which I already have installed, what do you guys think I should run battery wise? Thanks in advance
I wouldn't think there would be a heat or power difference but hooking up one amp for the subs would be easier and cleaner than 2.

BoatFloating
03-31-2005, 10:28 PM
Is there a power difference and heat issue with either running 2 500/1 or a 1000/1?
If I'm running one of those choices, plus a 300/4 which I already have installed, what do you guys think I should run battery wise? Thanks in advance
The only down side of JL amps is they like to use power (batteries) so I would think at least 2 batteries for the stereo is in order. They're great amps for sure....
Cornwater, big baller 3 W6's
:)

STV_Keith
04-01-2005, 07:49 AM
If you haven't already bought the amp, the HiFonics Brutus is a Class D, 1500w mono amp that's cheap and pushes big power. I think $270 shipped was the going rate last I looked. I considered that one, but ended up matching my other RF amp instead.

STV_Keith
04-01-2005, 07:50 AM
NoTalent - just come over for the party - don't need your boat!

ROZ
04-01-2005, 10:14 AM
If you haven't already bought the amp, the HiFonics Brutus is a Class D, 1500w mono amp that's cheap and pushes big power.
The old gray mare just ain't what she use to be... :D

STV_Keith
04-01-2005, 01:30 PM
I concede, I'm sure ROZ is much more up on these thing than I am. ;)

Firewater
04-01-2005, 01:34 PM
so having 1 battery for starting and two for the stereo should be enough for a good day at the sandbar?

ROZ
04-01-2005, 02:06 PM
I concede, I'm sure ROZ is much more up on these thing than I am. ;)
NOT, slipping more and more as of late......lol.. I was referring to Hifonics use to be the sheit back in the day...
If I didn't have a wedding to attend tomorrow up in Marina Del Rey, I'd be at RWYB for sure... Like to check hear those subs you rave about!

BoatFloating
04-01-2005, 07:13 PM
so having 1 battery for starting and two for the stereo should be enough for a good day at the sandbar?
maybe half a day....
:rollside:

Firewater
04-02-2005, 05:52 PM
whats the big deal about those odessey batteries? what makes them the new hot ticket?