CJERK, With all of these underwater products, the variables are many. Props, struts, and rudders are made from 4130 metal, then welded, shaped and heat-treated, then in many cases re-shaped before they are finished (especially props). Any variable in the welding or the heat-treating can produce a part that may not last as long as we would expect. I know that, more than likely, the rudders and hardware that you guys are having tested is probably 20-30 years old. So, I would not call it common or uncommon. Tom...