I would run the comp over the edelbrock, I pulled a 272 Comp out of my 350, idled so well I thought is was a stocker. Put in a cam very similar to the Comp 284, which is on the edge for an I/O, due to the idle speed and low vacumn. The 268 would be a good all around cam for a mostly stock motor, the performer is for lowere RPM street use, take a look at the spec's and recommended usage. If you have other concerns I'd call Comp's techline adn discuss it wth the guys who really know the ins and outs of the cams.