Like I said a hundred times... anything with "Atkins" on it is a scam. It is just lower carbs, sometimes, than the options. They are not zero carbs. A lot of times they file it under net carbs, and that is just as bad in my opinion.
You don't see an "Atkins approved" on the three porterhouses I bought yesterday, or the flat of eggs or my new bacon with no carbs. Not on the chicken wings and hot sauce or chicken fajitas (no tortillas of course) I have been living on for the last week. That is what I eat.
You can cram the bars, shakes and other crap as far as I am concerned.